H-1B Transfers in a Spin-Off Without Amended Petitions
Nonimmigrant Visas

The Situation

A spin-off is like a corporate New Year’s party. An immigration counsel’s job at these events is to be the only person who is sober.

One fall I received news that my long-term corporate client would spin off part of its research and development into a new company come January. The company worked in genomics, and I had represented it since it was a startup with one employee. It had grown to several offices around the world and close to 100 employees in the U.S. I suppose it was fitting for that particular company to want to split into two, like a cell that can’t help dividing itself.

I was in charge of making sure that the transition was smooth and nothing got lost or tangled up in the shuffle. I would represent both companies, before and after the spin-off. The question was what would happen to the H-1B workers moving to the new company: did each of them need a new petition?

The Easy Way and the Hard Way

There are two ways of dealing with mergers, acquisitions, and spin-offs: the easy way or the hard way. When the job itself changes, or moves to a place that needs a new labor condition application, the regulation requires an amended or new petition. 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(h)(2)(i)(E); Matter of Simeio Solutions, LLC, 26 I&N Dec. 542 (AAO 2015). Each amended or new petition invites renewed scrutiny: of the specialty occupation, of the worker’s maintenance of nonimmigrant status, and of the details of the corporate reorganization. Each also comes with its own legal and filing fees and costs.

And where the job stays the same, but for the changing identity of the employer, there’s an easy way. The statute does not require an amended petition when a new corporate entity succeeds to the interests and obligations of the original employer and the terms and conditions of employment remain the same but for the identity of the petitioner. INA § 214(c)(10), 8 U.S.C. § 1184(c)(10). The Department of Labor’s regulation anticipates such transactions. After an “acquisition, merger, ‘spin-off,’ or other such action,” the new employer need not file new labor condition applications or new H-1B petitions. 20 C.F.R. § 655.730(e)(1). Instead, what’s required is a memorandum in each worker’s public access file, with no notice to the USCIS at all.

In my case, some employees were being transferred to the new company, some were staying, and some were leaving altogether. Ultimately, eight employees chose to transfer, each with his or her own certified labor condition application. These were mostly bioinformatics scientists and related professionals engaged in genomics research. Each had to keep the same job, in the same area of intended employment, on the same terms and conditions. INA § 214(c)(10); 20 C.F.R. § 655.715.

The memorandum listed each of the eight labor condition applications and its date of certification. It described the new company’s actual wage system and gave its Employer Identification Number. It closed with a notarized statement in which the new company assumed all obligations, liabilities, and undertakings arising from the attestations in its predecessor’s applications. 20 C.F.R. §§ 655.730(e)(1)(i)–(iv), 655.760(a)(7). A copy went into each of the eight public access files. The transfers waited for the spin-off to take effect in January.

The Number That Made a New Employer

For the H-1B rules, the new company’s Employer Identification Number was one of the four items the memorandum had to list. The exemption from new filings applies “regardless of whether there is a change” in that number. 20 C.F.R. § 655.730(e)(1).

The PERM rules read the same number differently. When an employer sponsors its own employee, the Department of Labor looks at the experience the employee had at the time of hire. Experience gained afterward, in a substantially comparable job, cannot be required of U.S. applicants. 20 C.F.R. § 656.17(i)(3). For that rule, “employer” means “an entity with the same Federal Employer Identification Number.” 20 C.F.R. § 656.17(i)(5)(i). The new company’s number was different. Everything the eight had learned at the parent was now experience gained before the new company hired them, and it could count in any PERM case the new company filed for them. That proved useful when the cases built on that experience were certified.

The spin-off had one more use. Employees of either company could now write expert letters for the other’s petitions, on their own employer’s letterhead, because they no longer worked for the petitioner. They still had intimate knowledge of its processes and operations.

The Result

The spin-off went through with nothing lost and nothing tangled. The memorandum took about an hour of work per transferee. Eight amended or new petitions would have meant eight new labor condition applications, eight sets of legal and filing fees, and eight independent adjudications by USCIS. The H-1B extensions the new company later filed for the transferred employees drew no requests for evidence.

One memorandum did the work of eight petitions.

Case study title

Let’s talk strategy for your case.