I-140 NOIR Withdrawn Over an Invented English Language Requirement
EB-3

The Situation

Every now and then a case blurs the line between funny ha-ha and funny strange. This one was not even mine to begin with. A colleague at another firm had received a Notice of Intent to Revoke an approved I-140 petition for an EB-3 skilled worker and brought it to me to answer. The notice listed several revocation grounds, including one I had never seen in an immigrant visa case. Here is how the NOIR put it:

“It was also determined that the beneficiary does not speak any English. […] When asked what his job duties would be he had no ideal [sic]; all he could say was that he was going to be a distribution manager.”

The USCIS examiner parroted the consul’s findings from the visa interview, sent the notice without proofreading, and called it a day. He was not troubled in the least that his finding on English could not be traced to any statute or regulation governing immigrant visas for skilled workers. Answering a NOIR can be boring. This one was a pleasure to work on.

The Requirement That Wasn’t There

The law here is not complicated, which made the NOIR all the more remarkable. The regulation defines a skilled worker, at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(l)(2):

Skilled worker means an alien who is capable, at the time of petitioning for this classification, of performing skilled labor (requiring at least two years training or experience), not of a temporary or seasonal nature, for which qualified workers are not available in the United States. Relevant post-secondary education may be considered as training for the purposes of this provision.

English is not in it. The regulation leaves the requirements of a particular job to the labor certification. This one, approved by the Department of Labor, spelled out every qualification the position demanded. English was not among them. The form’s box for “Other Special Requirements” was blank. What the position did require was four years of experience in the job offered. The job was managing produce distribution. The NOIR listed its duties: keeping records of prices and sales volume, preparing daily reports, maintaining inventory, settling differences between the customers and the company, and supervising other employees.

Arguably, the last two duties call for a basic command of English. And yet, welding such common sense to the law would take nothing less than rethinking and rewriting two sets of federal regulations. Labor certification itself is an engineering solution to a common-sense problem, with predictable results: it solves one big problem at the cost of creating many small ones. Omitting English here was not an oversight. A labor certification is not the employer’s wish list. Every requirement on it is a filter, a lawful ground for turning away a U.S. worker, so each must be normal for the occupation or justified to the Department of Labor as a business necessity. To require English, this employer would have had to show the work could not be done without it, and to explain, by fair, objective, and verifiable criteria, why it rejected each U.S. worker whose English was not good enough. Good luck with that. Imagine the employer being sued for discrimination by a native English speaker rejected as insufficiently proficient. Say, for using “it ain’t” or “I says” during a job interview.

Education, work experience, training, and documented skills remain the only qualifications that matter in an EB-2 or EB-3 labor certification case. Broadly speaking, from EB-5 up through EB-1, no employment-based preference category requires even basic English proficiency. In theory, a foreign executive could immigrate to run a Fortune 500 company without speaking a word of English (the board might object, but the law would not). When Congress cares about something, it knows how to ask. So far, it has asked for English only from immigrants working in health care. A visa-screen worker (a nurse or a physical therapist, for instance) must pass an English examination before receiving a visa (INA § 212(a)(5)(C)(ii); 8 C.F.R. § 212.15(g)). A foreign physician must show competence in oral and written English (INA § 212(a)(5)(B)(ii)). English can still matter where the job calls for a state license that, in turn, requires English. This job was not one of those.

Even in naturalization, where the law does test English, the bar is set deliberately low. A naturalization applicant must show basic conversational skills and rudimentary literacy (INA § 312(a)(1); 8 C.F.R. § 312.1(c); USCIS Policy Manual, vol. 12, pt. E, ch. 2); the writing test boils down to a single simple sentence, such as “Washington, D.C. is the capital of the United States.” If that is the standard for new citizens, who have lived and worked in the country for years, how can an immigrant visa applicant be expected to exceed it?

For over a century, there has been no English requirement for new immigrants, and the legislative priority behind that is transparent. In 1917, when Congress made immigrants prove they could read, it let them choose the language: English, “or some other language or dialect, including Hebrew or Yiddish” (Immigration Act of 1917, § 3, 39 Stat. 874). In 1924, Congress rationed immigration by national origin and left the test alone. In 1952, Congress kept the test and dropped the word English; an immigrant had only to “read and understand some language or dialect” (INA § 212(a)(25), 66 Stat. 163). The same Act gave its first preference to immigrants needed for their “high education, technical training, specialized experience, or exceptional ability” (INA § 203(a)(1)). Then as now, the law’s priority for the new arrival is self-sufficiency — not to learn the new language, but to make himself understood at a basic level, quickly enough to function in the job market first, and in society at large a distant second. In plain English: it’s what you bring to the American table that matters, not whether you can speak at the table.

A New Ground of Inadmissibility, Invented at the Window

The State Department’s own manual for consular officers treats English as essential in only two cases, at 9 FAM 302.1-5(B)(9):

Proficiency in English is essential if an employer specifies on Part A of Form ETA-750, Application for Alien Employment Certification, that knowledge of English is required for satisfactory job performance, or in the case of a graduate of a medical school.

Clearly, neither was the case here. The consul judged the man’s English by ear and took it upon himself to mint a new ground of inadmissibility: failure to speak English to the satisfaction of the consular officer. By that method, the consul might as well have asked the man to do push-ups and recommended revocation when he tired.

The Grounds That Came with It

The NOIR’s other grounds were no better. The man confirmed that he would be a distribution manager, and that was held against him; he had given a suspiciously correct answer. Then the NOIR dismissed the work-experience letter in a single sentence: “The beneficiary provided a letter of recommendation from an unknown person, dated June 16, 2004, however the name, place or date was not mentioned.” In fact, the translated letter was signed by the man’s former employer, who clearly identified himself, his business, the dates of employment, and the duties performed. USCIS described a letter it had not read.

The NOIR also called the man’s prior employment unverifiable without describing any attempt to verify it. Verifying it would be challenging, indeed. The employer’s business, where the man had worked for thirteen years, was in Iraq. I included a CNN article as an exhibit in my response to prove that, in the aftermath of the U.S.-led invasion, nothing was left of the business or its vicinity except ruins. So the consulate essentially demanded the man prove that a business destroyed in the war still existed, and counted his failure against him. Not funny.

An Assumed National Language

The NOIR concluded: “The beneficiary does not have the language and qualifications to work in the United States.” So I added one more point, which I could not in good conscience keep from USCIS. In 2009, the United States had no declared official language. (It would not have one until March 1, 2025, and then only by executive order [Exec. Order No. 14224, 90 Fed. Reg. 11363].)

Of course, the states have done their own declaring. Nebraska wrote English into its constitution in 1920. Illinois was first to act by statute, in 1923, and chose another name for the language: it “shall be known hereafter as the ‘American’ language and not as the ‘English’ language.” (The legislature reversed the change in 1969.) Hawaii has had two official languages since 1978, English and Hawaiian. Alaska added twenty Native languages to English in 2014. As of 2026, about thirty of the fifty states have formally declared English their official language. The state where this man was headed is not among them.

And that is the funny-strange part: the man failed the consular officer’s improvised English test while seeking to immigrate to a country that had not even made English its official language.

The Result

Two months after my response, USCIS withdrew the NOIR. The file went back to the consulate for a second interview. After so many words, I had nothing more to say on the matter. Nor did the consulate, apparently.

Case study title

Let’s talk strategy for your case.