The Situation
This L-1B raised almost philosophical questions underneath routine procedural ones: What is evidence? What is not evidence? How does one decide? I wish I were still in college reading Plato’s Republic and arguing with classmates over its definition of justice.
The petitioner was a bioinformatics and genomics research company I had represented since it was a startup. It had grown to two U.S. offices, about 100 employees and several overseas subsidiaries. The beneficiary was a key R&D engineer working for one of the overseas subsidiaries. The petitioner needed him stateside because the logistics of cross-border R&D were getting in the way of its progress. We didn’t get lucky playing the H-1B lottery. J-1 was not an option. The L-1B was the only route.
It was a good L-1B, mind you, not an L-1A that somehow fell short. The engineer had been with the petitioner’s subsidiary abroad for a year and a half. He rewrote the company’s flagship data extraction tool. The tool recovered sequences the industry-standard tool missed, and it scaled to large numbers of genomic regions. The tool was commercially valuable. Its documentation, however, was scarce.
So the challenge was to make USCIS see what we had to show them, and not just see it, but look at it in a different way, the way a viewer reads a third dimension into a two-dimensional drawing. The petition was anchored in expert evidence of the R&D, the engineer’s role and individual contribution, and the tool’s importance for the company’s market share. The algorithm was proprietary, and the petitioner guarded it zealously. The facts could only be established through the people who knew them and could speak about them for the record.
The legal argument tracked the USCIS memorandum issued to bring some clarity to a regulation that defines “specialized knowledge” in a single sentence. 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(D). The regulation tells us what specialized knowledge is. The memorandum tells us what kind of evidence can prove it.
The USCIS memorandum in force when I filed holds that knowledge may be special or advanced, and that either way the petitioner must establish a favorable comparison, against similarly employed workers in the industry or against the rest of the employer’s own operations. USCIS, L-1B Adjudications Policy, PM-602-0111, at 7–8 (Aug. 17, 2015). It lists the factors that count and the evidence that can show them: training records, manuals, comparisons among parallel employees. Id. at 12–13. The last line is an open door: a petitioner “may submit any other evidence it chooses.” I chose expert letters. USCIS has since moved the standard, nearly word for word, into its Policy Manual at Volume 2, Part L, Chapter 4.
“Simply Going on Record”
The RFE from the Texas Service Center’s premium processing unit came twelve days after the petition was filed. USCIS decided, in nine pages, that the evidence I had submitted did not qualify as evidence. What was it then?
The RFE had an answer:
“However, USCIS recognizes the submitted evidence, simply going on record stating the beneficiary’s qualifications without submitting documentary evidence is insufficient to establish the beneficiary and the position qualify for the classification.”
USCIS had looked at the drawing and seen only two dimensions. The phrase “going on record” came from two precedent decisions in which petitioners expected their own statements to count as evidence. In one, a California pottery maker claimed that training for its Mexican trainees (among them a kilnman’s helper, a caster’s assistant and a wareman) was unavailable in Mexico, and offered nothing but its own word. Matter of Treasure Craft of California, 14 I&N Dec. 190 (Reg’l Comm’r 1972). In the other, an investor whose company had bought a Howard Johnson’s motor lodge said his money came from savings and the sale of “a house” and “our business,” and produced no deed or sales contract for either. Matter of Soffici, 22 I&N Dec. 158, 164–65 (Assoc. Comm’r 1998). In both, the only witness was the petitioner.
Unlike in those cases, none of the three experts I brought in worked for the petitioner: a vice president of R&D operations was at another company, and two assistant professors of computer engineering taught at different universities. See Matter of D-R-, 25 I&N Dec. 445, 460 n.13 (BIA 2011) (expert witness testimony may be given different weight depending on the extent of the expert’s qualifications or the relevance, reliability, and probative value of the testimony), remanded on other grounds sub nom. Radojkovic v. Holder, 599 F. App’x 646 (9th Cir. 2015).
On the evidence of the beneficiary’s qualifying employment at the overseas subsidiary, USCIS rejected the employment confirmation letter from the subsidiary’s director, who knew and supervised the beneficiary’s work day-to-day, and suggested a letter from its Human Resources Department instead. The subsidiary had no Human Resources Department. I added social security statements of the beneficiary’s earnings for his entire employment there, and a letter from the subsidiary’s accountant, who had custody of its personnel records and direct knowledge of its payroll.
“Any Engineer”
The RFE’s other objection was that the beneficiary’s training was what every engineer in his position receives:
“It seems reasonable to expect your Engineer professionals to be trained in your technologies and tools and for them to have duties that directly relate to the utilization and/or customization of said technologies and tools.”
His knowledge, the RFE concluded, was not advanced in relation to “that of any Engineer.”
My RFE response put numbers on that training. The company’s director of scientific operations, who had written its R&D training manual, attached the manual and set standard onboarding against what the beneficiary received: over 100 hours of additional training in algorithm development and advanced sequencing practice, each session led by a senior scientist. He had been one of those instructors, which made his letter, with the manual, primary evidence of the training. The training cost the petitioner in the low five figures. Two of his four instructors had since left the company; one of them, now at another employer, supplied the syllabus. The company had also sent the beneficiary to a five-day summer institute in computational genomics that, according to its organizer, only about 15 professionals worldwide had completed. The company “does not offer or require this additional training from other R&D engineers.” Only two other employees in the U.S. matched his knowledge of algorithm development, and both were committed to other work. That is a factor USCIS’s own memorandum lists: knowledge that “cannot be easily transferred or taught to another individual without significant economic cost or inconvenience,” with training manuals on its list of qualifying evidence. PM-602-0111 at 8, 12–13.
The Result
USCIS approved the petition sixteen days after the response. The consulate then took five months of administrative processing to issue the visa.
Two and a half years after the approval, the L-1B extension petition, built on the same expert letters, drew a second RFE. This one did not dismiss them as going on record. It asked different questions:
“You submitted letters of support and training documentation for the beneficiary, but you did not indicate the number of other employees that have taken the same training as the beneficiary. You have not provided evidence documenting the overall amount of training received by the beneficiary and evidence that the training was extensive or considered specialized or advanced. You have not provided a comparison of the beneficiary’s training and experience to others in the field or within the organization.”
The response answered each one. On the number, a new letter from the company’s principal scientist confirmed that no other R&D engineer at the company had received the beneficiary’s training. On the amount, other R&D engineers received four days of additional training; the beneficiary had received ten days, more than 100 hours in all. On the comparison, only one other employee in the U.S. matched his knowledge of algorithm development, and that employee was committed to other work; another letter estimated that fewer than a thousand people in the country could perform in his position at the required level. By then the beneficiary was also one of two people at the company in the U.S. who could troubleshoot complex workflows on tools a former employee had built. USCIS approved the extension nine days after the response. Then the consulate again took six weeks of administrative processing to issue the visa.
I remember this case each time expert opinion has to supply the proof, because the facts cannot be shown through conventional documents. We can bet on USCIS seeing only a hat when shown a drawing of a boa constrictor digesting an elephant. And once we persuade them that it is not a hat, we must be ready to argue that this particular boa constrictor is unlike the others: it swallowed an elephant whole.