O-1A Approval for a Private Equity Investor
Nonimmigrant Visas

The Situation

A private equity investor came to me for a second opinion. Another attorney had filed an O-1A petition for him, with his own company as the petitioner. It drew a long request for evidence, and his attorney’s position on how best to answer it kept shifting.

The RFE ran to fourteen pages. It began with the petitioner itself:

The record indicates that you may be self-petitioning, which is not allowed by regulation for the O classification.

The USCIS examiner had also searched the web and found the petitioner in a shared office location, which “casts doubt upon the legitimacy of your business and the validity of the employment offered.” From there the RFE found the expert consultation insufficient, and the evidence insufficient under every one of the six claimed criteria. While the petition was pending, my client received a job offer from another firm that he considered joining. The question was whether to answer the RFE or start over.

Starting Over

I reviewed the record. Like many others, the filed petition appeared to cover the criteria, and yet the overall impression was of a jigsaw puzzle with many missing parts. The legal argument boiled down to paperwork labeling: this is for X, that is for Y. In short, the presentation was uninspired. How would you grade the overall effort? my client asked. C+ at best, I said.

I advised him to withdraw the petition and file a second one on the new job offer. He accepted the offer and introduced me to his prospective employer. The petitioner was now someone other than the beneficiary.

The record lacked focus and specificity. It wasn’t even clear what the big picture was. Some of the letters from the first filing could be used again, but not to support an effective legal argument. The regulation asks for three of eight criteria. 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(B). I told my client I would focus on his achievements in three specific areas, and only on the strongest criteria. All other evidence would play a supporting role. I would rather not stretch the legal argument’s credibility to fit every possible criterion.

We worked on drafting and obtaining testimonial letters covering more than a decade of his career. Each letter had to discuss his specific contributions and achievements in as much detail as possible. What began as my visualization of a winning case became a sketch, then a working draft. Then we proceeded to fill in the details. Even precisely defining the field of endeavor turned out not to be so straightforward. Private equity investors and managers work in a wide variety of fields and settings. We defined his as investment management in private equity, and anchored the definition in authoritative reference sources.

Who Speaks for an Industry

The standard is “a level of expertise indicating that the person is one of the small percentage who have arisen to the very top of the field of endeavor.” 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(o)(3)(ii). The facts were compelling. They read like billboards on the argument highway. As a managing director of a state-run investment fund, my client had launched three domestic industries from scratch: LED lighting, solar power, and optical fiber. Before that, at a major industrial company, he had brought in billions of dollars in new investment capital and helped structure some of its most profitable deals.

The first petition had supported his original-contributions claim with letters from his colleagues and from companies he had invested in or served as a director or board member. The first RFE had already dismissed them in one sentence:

Any letter from a representative of an organization on which the beneficiary holds a position or in which he or a company he represents holds substantial investments is not considered an objective source.

The new petition anchored the argument much higher. We obtained testimonials from the heads of the national associations representing each of the three industries my client had helped establish. Each spoke for an entire industry. One began:

Ours is the only national professional association in the industry. As our association’s chief executive, I serve as our industry spokesman and thus have the authority to speak on its behalf.

The solar association director wrote that his sector “could not have emerged” without my client’s efforts.

I applied the same evidence-upgrade method to the rest of the record. The first petition’s judging evidence was a press release that, in the RFE’s words, identified him “only as an attendee, not as a judge.” The second petition offered the solar association’s director, who had served with him on the judging panel of a solar-energy competition. The first petition’s consultation letter had been found insufficient. The second petition asked that the requirement be waived, because no U.S. peer group or labor organization for private equity investors exists, and where none exists the Service decides on the record. 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(o)(5)(i)(G). In the alternative, we offered a letter from a founder of one of the world’s largest venture capital firms.

The first RFE had reduced my client’s role to “the director of a single business group within this large national corporation.” In the second petition, the fund’s executive chairman explained that my client’s investment decisions required approval from the executive board and from two government ministries. On the remuneration criterion, the RFE had found it “not possible to determine” that he was ever highly paid. In the second petition, his country’s labor statistics agency supplied the average pay for his position. He had earned 27.79 times that average in his worst year and 187.99 times in his best.

But where the record was thin, my brief said so and moved on. The first petition had claimed published material about him on the strength of press releases. The second offered the press coverage only as corroboration of sustained achievement, and conceded it might not qualify under that criterion on its own. It went in as comparable evidence instead, the route the regulation opens when a criterion does not readily apply to the occupation. 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(C).

One Question

The new petition took about a month of intensive labor and coordination to prepare and file. Seven days later, USCIS issued an RFE. It asked for only one thing:

you are asked to provide the worksite location (full address) where the beneficiary will be performing his duties.

The worksite address was already listed on the I-129 and in the employer’s job offer letter. Instead of pointing that out, I drafted and sent the employer’s response. The petition was approved four days later, eleven days after filing.

Not an EB-1A

My client arrived in the United States with his family a few weeks later. Conventional wisdom’s next step would have been an EB-1A on the same record. It is the strategy most often pitched for a record like his, and even my client was already primed for it. I advised against it. On these facts, the EB-1A was a much harder sell, and I didn’t want an uphill battle at my client’s expense. I wanted us to reach the same outcome through PERM, in the EB-2 category, on a job offer from his U.S. employer, with practically no risk of denial. Our goal is the destination, not the ego or the journey. Instead of trying to fly first class, I advised taking the train.

The Result

Within six months of his arrival, we filed the labor certification. It was certified in 47 days. The I-140 was approved ten days after filing, without an RFE. The adjustment of status applications for my client and his wife, filed the following month, were approved nine months later.

Twenty-one months after the second O-1A was filed, my client and his wife had their green cards. Five years after that, they became U.S. citizens.

Case study title

Let’s talk strategy for your case.